Last updated: October 15, 2021

Do you like to eat fresh bread and want it to keep longer? But freezing is not an option for you? Then you should consider buying a bread bin. A bread bin extends the shelf life of your baked goods by several days and allows you to eat them immediately without defrosting. For many people, the bread bin has become an indispensable part of the kitchen. But what are the different types and what criteria do you have to consider when buying?

In our bread box test 2021, we show you the best and most useful storage boxes in various categories. We also give you important information and useful tips on how to store bread properly. Whether you choose a bread bin with a lid, a bread bin with a hinged lid or a rolling bread bin, you will find the best bread bins on the market.




Summary

  • A bread box definitely belongs in your kitchen if you like to consume bread often and are tired of disposing of leftover bread. In the right bread box, your bread will stay fresh for days after you buy it.
  • Materials from which bread boxes are usually made are stainless steel, sheet metal, wood, clay and enamel. Plastic containers are also available.
  • When buying, also consider how much space you have on your kitchen counter and how large the quantities of bread you want to store are.

The Best Bread Box: Our Picks

Guide: Questions you should ask yourself before buying a bread box

Why a bread box?

Of course, you can also freeze your home-made or bought bread. But since this is associated with certain negative aspects, a good bread box is often the better alternative.

Loaves of bread and pre-cut slices of bread that you store in the freezer have the disadvantage that they cannot be eaten immediately. They must first be baked or defrosted for hours. This is not necessary with bread from the bread box.

A high-quality bread container that can be neatly closed will keep your baked goods fresh for several days if you observe certain things. On the one hand, this has the advantage that you will have to buy or bake bread less often, allowing you to use your time in other ways. On the other hand, the longer shelf life of the bread significantly reduces the amount of food that ends up in the rubbish.

What types of bread bins are there and what are the advantages and disadvantages?

Basically, we can distinguish between three different types of bread bins:

  • Bread box with lid
  • Bread box with hinged lid
  • Rolling bread box

Based on the different closure methods, shapes and your own preference, one or the other bread bin is more suitable for you. Since each box has certain characteristics that can affect the storage of the loaves of bread, there are different advantages and disadvantages for each of these types.

In the following section, we will explain the differences in the lids and shape of each bread bin in more detail so that you can decide for yourself which bread bin is better for you. In this way, we would like to make your purchase decision easier. We also describe the advantages and disadvantages of each type in more detail.

How does a bread box with a lid work - what are the advantages and disadvantages?

A bread box with a lid is characterised above all by its simple and straightforward design. Mostly, these bread boxes are also made of different materials. If the lid is made of wood, it can also be used as a chopping board. However, the lid must always be put down beforehand and put back on the bread box after use.

The simple design of the bread box also has another advantage: these models are often available at a reasonable price. Exceptions are models that are made of expensive woods.

Advantages
  • Simple design
  • Usually inexpensive
Disadvantages
  • Lid has to be put down and put back on again

How does a bread box with a hinged lid work what are the advantages and disadvantages?

A bread box with a hinged lid does not consist of two different parts like a bread bin with a separate lid. The lid is mounted directly on the box with a hinge. This means that the lid does not have to be constantly taken off and put back on, but simply folded open and closed. The hinge can therefore also wear out over time.

The lunch box looks very modern with its hinged lid and can therefore also be bought in different materials and designs. However, the hinge can wear out over time.

Advantages
  • Modern
  • Quick to open and close
Disadvantages
  • Hinge can wear out over time

How does a rolling bread box work and what are the advantages and disadvantages?

A rolling bread box is the fanciest and most elegant option to store your bread and keep it fresh. Unlike lidded bread bins, the locking mechanism is fixed to the bin like a hinged-lid bin. However, the lid is integrated and is simply pushed on. This saves space and prevents the lid from falling shut on its own.

This lunch box convinces with its retro look and elegant design. The only disadvantage is that the rolling mechanism can break more quickly than a hinge with a hinged lid.

Advantages
  • Retro look
  • Elegant design
Disadvantages
  • Mechanism can break more easily

Buying criteria: You can compare and evaluate bread boxes based on these factors

You should not base your decision for or against acertain bread box only on the cost of buying it, but also on other important criteria.

These include..

Before we give you detailed information on the points just mentioned, we would like to point out something relevant: Every bread box should allow good air circulation. Bread "breathes", i.e. releases moisture. Therefore, make sure that your bread bin has specifically placed air holes so that moisture can escape and mould is prevented.

In addition, every bread box should close really well. So the lid should not slip or be warped. Otherwise, too much air will get to your baked goods, causing them to dry out.

Different types of bread boxes

It is quite possible that you will be confronted by the salesperson in the shop with the question of what type of bread bin you are looking for. Read this section in detail and you will have an answer.

Rolling bread box

To open the rolling bread bin, simply slide the lid open. It slides along two rails from the bottom to the top and disappears inside the box. This has the advantage that you don 't have to plan for any extra space when opening.

A disadvantage of such wooden bread boxes is that the wood can warp due to moisture, so that after some time you may have the problem that you can either no longer slide the lid down or up properly or only with somewhat greater effort. In addition, you may hear an unpleasant rattling sound when opening the bread bin if it is made entirely of wood.

Examples in this category look particularly elegant with a so-called visor lid. Here, too, you simply slide the lid up or back to remove the bread.

Models with lifting lids

Lifting lids are found on bread pots and some square bread boxes. If the lid is particularly heavy, for example on ceramic or clay containers, you may need two hands to open it or at least have to put the lid down while you remove the bread. Heavy lids are also relatively noisy when opening and closing.

Did you know that researchers believe that bread was baked 10,000 years ago?

Why people came up with the idea of baking mixtures of water and grain can probably be explained by the preservation of food and the conservation of scarce resources. Baking was considered the first and best way to preserve food for a longer period of time.

Bread box with hinged lid

In bread bins with a hinged lid, the lid is folded back, or, in the case of a front lid, forward. Bear in mind that when the bread bin is open, the flap also takes up space. You can therefore not place some models directly against the wall, but must reserve extra free space for the lid.

The shape of your bread box

What shape are the baked goods you bake and mainly consume? And where should your bread box ultimately be placed? These are two questions you may not have asked yourself yet, but ideally they will save you frustration.

If your main bread consumption is elongated loaves, boxed bread or toast, you are certainly well served by a cuboid bread bin. Yeast plaits, rolls or sweet, rather dry biscuits such as croissants are also better accommodated in a square or oval container than in a circular one.

Do you own a breadmaker and do your homemade bread loaves therefore have the characteristic cube or cuboid shape? In this case, too, we recommend you go for the square bread bin.

If, on the other hand, bread types such as paneer or flatbread often end up in your shopping basket or if you use a round bread baking tin, a round bread bin is certainly the better choice. Round bread containers are also an option for you if you have enough space on your kitchen counter or place the container directly on the dining table.

However, they are rather unsuitable if your kitchen is already cluttered. In such a case, an angular box is again advisable, as you can accommodate it more easily and possibly also place something small on top.

Ceramic, stainless steel, clay or wood? Materials from which bread boxes are made

Even if you have decided to buy a bread box, you may still be asking yourself which material is best for storing bread.

Here is an overview of common materials a bread box can be made of and the associated advantages and disadvantages.

Ceramic

Bread pans made of ceramic are characterised by the fact that they are easy to clean. Some can even be put in the dishwasher. While many models have both pot and lid made of ceramic, there are also pots with a lid made of bamboo or other wood. You can usually also use the wooden lid as a bread cutting board.

Ceramic bread pans often score points with their chic design, but they have the disadvantage of being very heavy (up to 2.8 kg). Bread bins made of stoneware or earthenware also belong to the "ceramic" category, as they are ceramic products. They have more or less the same characteristics.

Clay

If you choose a container made of clay, you also have to reckon with a rather high weight. A large, oval bread pot can weigh around 4.5 kg. Since the lid is usually relatively heavy, you may need both hands to lift it, and opening it is relatively noisy compared to tins made of other materials. Bread tins made of clay absorb the moisture released by the bread well.

If you are bothered by the somewhat rough surface of a clay bread box without glaze, you can also choose glazed versions. Make sure that the glaze is properly applied and as evenly distributed as possible.

Some bread pots are also suitable for the oven. You can therefore also use them as bread baking pans. However, before you do this, please read the manufacturer's information.

Stainless steel

If you already have other kitchen gadgets made of stainless steel, e.g. kettle and toaster, and like to have it uniform, a stainless steel bread tin is a good option for you. Apart from a quite noble look , it scores with the fact that it is also easy to clean. The important thing here is that it really is real stainless steel and not a mixture (e.g. stainless steel and sheet metal), otherwise the box can rust when you wipe it out with a damp cloth.

Steel kitchen appliances always look high quality. If you already own other metal appliances, a bread bin made of this material will fit well in your kitchen.

Sheet steel

The same problem can arise with bread boxes made of sheet steel: With their casual retro look, they can be a real eye-catcher in your kitchen, but sheet steel can also rust over time, which can result in additional costs for you, for example if you need to purchase a rust removal agent or a new bin.

Wood

One material that a variety of lunch boxes are made from is wood. Similar to clay, wood absorbs moisture from bread well. Perhaps even more important than bread bins made of other materials is that bread bins made of wood allow air circulation, for example through air holes, otherwise the bread will dry out quickly.

Make sure that your product is food-safe, i.e. that the wood does not have any toxic protective coatings. Wooden bread boxes are not suitable for the dishwasher. An additional drawback that can occur after prolonged use is that the wood may warp, making it impossible to close the box properly.

Boxes made of wood are more suitable for bread, but they are not suitable for the dishwasher.

The biggest enemies of fresh bread are mould and dehydration, both of which are signs of poor storage. Ideally, a bread bin allows enough air in so that the bread doesn't dry out and enough moisture out so that the bread doesn't start to mould. (Photo: nathandumlao / unsplash.com)

Plastic

If possible, stay away from cheap, poorly made plastic bread containers. It's certainly not problematic if you take your snack to work in a plastic container, but for long-term bread storage, plastic is probably not the best option.

They are usually cheaper than bread boxes made of other materials and are often dishwasher safe, but they have the major disadvantage that sooner or later the bread will grow mould and become inedible because the moisture cannot escape from inside the container.

Material combinations

In your search for the perfect bread bin, you will also come across some that combine different materials. Common combinations are ceramic and wood, as well as stainless steel and plastic, glass or wood. In any case, it is important that the individual materials are well made, of high quality and match each other.

When buying a plastic bread pan, make sure that it is BPA-free.

Size also matters - dimensions and capacity of bread boxes

The size of your bread box should depend on how many bread eaters there are in your household, how much bread you buy (or bake) and consume, and how much space you have in your kitchen.

Caution: Do not equate the apparent size with the filling volume! With small bread boxes, it is logical to assume that not too much will fit inside, but with large bread boxes there can be relatively large differences between the outer and inner dimensions - sometimes even between 5 and 10 cm.

Did you know that the bread box became more important in post-war Europe?

During this time, an awareness for high-quality kitchen equipment arose in Europe, which was already established in America. Bread in particular was increasingly consumed after the Second World War and therefore had to be stored appropriately, for which bread boxes offered the perfect possibility.

Small or single bread boxes

Even with "single" bread boxes, you may find that the interior is much smaller than expected. These bread boxes are designed to keep small quantities of bread fresh. Nevertheless, they sometimes take up a lot of space, e.g. due to their fancy design.

So if you have little space, go for small bread boxes. There are models that are very wide but not long, and some that are narrow but extend far to the back.

At this point we have another tip for you: When buying, also consider whether the open bread bin needs more space than the closed one. This can be the case, for example, with hinged-lid versions.

Medium-sized bread boxes

Most bread boxes, crates and bread pots are designed for a household of 2-3 bread fans. So if it is quite common for you to have a medium-sized loaf of bread and a couple of rolls or two 1-kg loaves at home, we recommend an "average" bread bin (see table).

Maxi bread bin

But even if it is not unusual for you to store very large quantities of bread, there is a bin for you. In that case, it is best to choose an extra-large one.

To give you a better idea, we have picked out a few sample models for you and noted their dimensions and filling quantities in a table. Please consider the information contained in the table as a guide only and do not rely on the values given.

Description Dimensions (width x depth x height or dm x height) What fits in approximately? suitable household size
square, small, wide 20 x 28 x 16 1 medium bread + 2 rolls 1-2 persons
square, small, narrow 20 x 20 x 13.5 1/2 loaf + 1 roll 1-2 persons
square, average 40 x 20 x 15 2 medium loaves 3-4 persons
angular, large 50 x 27 x 20 2 large loaves 4(+) persons
round 30 x 15 1 round, medium loaf or 2-3 pieces of biscuit 1-2 persons

Brotaufbewahrung unterwegs

Natürlich gibt es auch noch viel kleinere Behälter zur Brotaufbewahrung – Sandwich- oder Brotboxen. Diese eignen sich hervorragend zum Mitnehmen des Schul- oder Jausenbrotes.

Da Sie sie aber in der Regel nur zur kurzfristigen Brotaufbewahrung verwenden, gelten dafür etwas andere Hauptkriterien. So sollten sie einerseits ein „Krümel-Chaos“ in der Tasche verhindern, also dichthalten, und andererseits dafür sorgen, dass Ihr Brot nicht austrocknet.

In der Regel gibt es hier keine wesentlichen Größenunterschiede. Die meisten Boxen passen ganz leicht in den normalen Schulranzen Ihres Kindes oder Ihre Handtasche.

Special features and extras

Somewhat more unusual and - and usually also somewhat more expensive - products or their manufacturers offer you one or two additional features:

  • Dishwasher-suitable: You can put the bread container or parts of it in the dishwasher and save washing it by hand.
  • Multifunctional lid: The lid doubles as a bread cutting board.
  • Touch-bin (storage) system: With some roll-top and hinged-lid bread bins, the lid opens itself when you touch it.
  • Manufacturer's warranty: Some manufacturers assure you that you can easily exchange the product within a certain period of time. Guarantees range from 2 to 10 years.

Conclusion: When buying your bread bin, there are several things you should keep in mind. We have tried here to give you the most important things to consider and hope to have made your decision easier.

Viele Tests haben ergeben, dass Brot unverpackt am längsten frisch hält. Am besten schmeckt Brot aber natürlich immer frisch vom Bäcker oder aus dem eigenen Backofen. (Foto: congerdesign / pixabay.com)
Reviews