Do you know the feeling when your eyes bite, itch or feel dry? As if you have a foreign body in your eye that makes you feel tight? You are not alone. Many people often suffer from dry eyes and feel the need to moisturise them with the help of unpleasant drops.
But there is a simpler solution for moisturising the eyes, namely with the help of an eye spray. To help you find out more about eye sprays, we have put together an eye spray test for you at 2022.
- 1 Weekly newsletter with the best personal finance tips
- 2 Summary
- 3 The Best Eye Spray: Our Picks
- 4 Buying and evaluation criteria for eye sprays
- 5 Guide: Frequently asked questions about eye sprays answered in detail
- 5.1 What is eye spray and how does it work?
- 5.2 When and for whom is the use of eye spray useful?
- 5.3 What types of eye sprays are there?
- 5.4 How should eye spray be dosed?
- 5.5 What are the alternatives to eye sprays?
- 5.6 What side effects can eye sprays have?
- 5.7 Why are preservative-free eye sprays important?
- Eye spray is used when the eye area should be moisturised, soothed and protected. It helps against itchy, burning and red eyes.
- The eye spray is sprayed onto the closed eyelid and thus the lipid-containing particles spread indirectly on the surface of the eye.
- The eye spray is often made from vegetable liposomes such as soy lecithin and phospholipids. Hyaluronic acid is also used, as is often the case with eye drops.
The Best Eye Spray: Our Picks
Buying and evaluation criteria for eye sprays
When buying eye spray, you can pay attention to various aspects, such as:
By making the right choice for you, you can save money and also ensure that you don't give your body anything it doesn't need. Therefore, always look for high quality and, if necessary, ask to see the manufacturer's certificates.
Reason for use
When deciding on the right eye spray, the first relevant factor is the reason why you want to use eye spray. People buy eye spray for various reasons, for example because they have itchy, burning or dry eyes.
Before you buy an eye spray product, find out why you suffer from one of the symptoms described so that you can then buy the right product. Not all eye sprays have the same ingredients and effects.
The reason for use and the effect are very close as a purchase criterion. When buying an eye spray, you should also consider what effect the product should have. This depends on the reason for use.
The purpose of spraying the eyelids is that small lipid-containing active substances land on the eyelid and eyelid edge and are distributed over the surface of the eye by blinking. The lipids contained in the eye spray support the outer lipid layer of the tear film and protect against evaporation.
Eye sprays are used to moisturise the eyes and protect against environmental influences such as pollen allergies. Eye sprays soothe the eyes and eyelids at the same time.
In addition, eye sprays are often used by contact lens wearers, as they often need product to moisturise against their dry eyes. Those affected often have a foreign body sensation in their eyes, which can be alleviated by using eye sprays.
In addition, eye spray can be used for tired eyes as it not only sprays the eye itself but also the eyelid. This has a refreshing and soothing effect on exhausted eyes.
If you want to buy an eye spray product, pay special attention to its ingredients. These ultimately influence the effect of the eye spray.
Liposomal eye spray is often sold for the treatment of dry eyes. The reason for using liposomal eye sprays is firstly that the person concerned probably has a disorder of the lipid layer, which can trigger the dry eyes.
For this reason, the eye sprays are made from a lipid base. Soy lecithin is often used for this purpose, as this is a plant-based active ingredient that naturally counteracts evaporation in the eye area.
To moisturise dry eyes, the film binder hyaluronic acid is also often used. However, this is more often used in eye drops than in eye sprays. However, liposomal eye sprays with hyaluronic acid are also sold.
Phospholipids are also commonly used as a liposomal eye spray. Often this is combined with euphrasia in its composition. This is also used for burning, itching and reddened eyes.
Many affected people use eye sprays with euphrasia when they suffer from pollen allergy. However, it can also be used for dry eyelids.
Eye sprays are sprayed onto the closed eyelids from a distance of about 10 to 20 cm. In doing so, the important particles pass from the eyelids over the surface of the eye, where they can eventually protect the eye from evaporation.
Spraying the eyelids achieves a relief of the eyes that lasts up to four hours. Thus, it is sufficient to use eye sprays between three to four times a day to relieve the feeling of foreign bodies or tension in the eyes.
Guide: Frequently asked questions about eye sprays answered in detail
What is eye spray and how does it work?
The eye spray is sprayed onto the closed eyelids, whereby the lipid-containing particles can stabilise the lipid layer of the tear film and thus have a moisturising, protective and refreshing effect. (1)
Moisturising for dry eyes
Affected people often suffer from dry eyes, which are manifested by feelings of tension or foreign bodies as well as itchy eyes.
By using eye spray, the eye can be moistened indirectly. Indirectly, because by spraying the lipid particles from the edges of the eyelids reach the surface of the eye and distribute themselves there.
The liopsomal eye spray thus stabilises the lipid layer of the tear film and ultimately protects the eyes from evaporation. (2)
Protective against environmental influences
A damaged lipid layer of the tear film often manifests itself as burning, itching or reddening of the eyes. This can happen due to environmental influences such as dust, exhaust fumes or even pollen.
Many people suffer from pollen allergy every year, which irritates the eyes a lot. By using eye sprays, it is possible to soothe the irritated eye area and protect it from pollen.
Refreshing for tired eyes
Daily use of smartphones, laptops and computers puts a strain on the eyes, causing them to tire very quickly. The eye spray can moisturise and refresh irritated eyes with a cooling effect.
This not only gives the eyes a good feeling, but also counteracts evaporation around the eyes.
When and for whom is the use of eye spray useful?
This is a common cause of dry eye because when the meibomian gland malfunctions, the lipid layer is damaged, which eventually dries out the eye.
Since liposomal eye sprays are made of liposomes, which stabilise the lipid layer of the tear film and thus prevent the eye from drying out, they are very helpful in Meimbomian gland dysfunction. (3)
The easy application of the eye spray makes it especially beneficial for people who do not like to use eye drops. (1)
Contact lens wearers often suffer from dry eyes, which is why they need the eye spray. When buying an eye spray, it is important to make sure that it is compatible with contact lens wearers.
What types of eye sprays are there?
There are also a few eye sprays whose main ingredient is hyaluronic acid, as is the case with many eye drops.
Three types of eye sprays are described below: Eye spray with soy lecithin, with hyaluronic acid and with phospholipids as the main ingredient.
|Eye spray with hyaluronic acid||Filmbindner hyaluronic acid as main active ingredient|
|Eye spray with soy lecithin||soy lecithin as main active ingredient as well as vitamins A/E|
|Eye spray with phospholipids||phospholipids as main active ingredient without sodium chloride|
In order to understand the difference between these three types of eye spray, they will now be explained in more detail.
Eye spray with hyaluronic acid
This type of eye spray does not contain a lipid-based ingredient like the other eye sprays, but the film binder hyaluronic acid. The film binder used binds the tear fluid and thus improves the moisturisation of the eye. (5)
Hyaluronic acid is more commonly used as an important ingredient in eye drops and is rarely used in the composition of eye sprays.
Eye spray with hyaluronic acid can be used for mild irritation of the eyes. Since this type of eye spray is not made with soy lecithin, it is well suited for people who are allergic to soy.
According to the package leaflet, the eye sprays with hyaluronic acid do not have any general side effects.
Eye spray with soy lecithin
Natural lipids are often used in the lipid-containing production of eye sprays. For example, most lipid-containing eye sprays consist of the main ingredient soy lecithin. Sodium chloride is often used as an additional ingredient.
The eye sprays with soy lecithin often differ only in the addition of other ingredients such as vitamin A or E.
This type of eye spray can be used for itchy, burning eyes as well as for contact lens wearers. According to the package insert, temporary irritation may occur after use.
Eye spray with phospholipids
This type of eye spray can also be used for irritated eyes and by contact lens wearers. The difference in this type also lies in the production of the eye spray. It mainly consists of the main active ingredient phospholipids and soy lecithin.
Unlike the other types of eye spray, sodium chloride is not used as an additional ingredient here, but euphrasia (eyebright) is often used. Euphrasia has an anti-inflammatory effect on conjunctivitis. (6, 7)
According to the package leaflet, there should also be no known side effects when using this product.
How should eye spray be dosed?
For more severe conditions, the eye spray can also be used more often than the amount mentioned. (8)
What are the alternatives to eye sprays?
However, the application is different. While the eye spray is sprayed onto the closed eyelids, the eye drops are dripped directly into the open eye.
In the case of dry eyes, the eye drops offer immediate and more intensive moistening of the eyes, as they are administered directly into the eyes. (8)
On the other hand, they are more difficult and unpleasant to use for many people. In addition, the eye spray can be applied without contact, which makes it easier to use on the go and does not smudge make-up. (2)
What side effects can eye sprays have?
However, there are some opinions that differ regarding the effects of eye sprays. For some people, the use of eye sprays does not deliver the promised effect, but only intensifies it at the moment of spraying or does not improve the current condition at all.
Such reactions during use may be due to the fact that the persons concerned may not tolerate an active ingredient used. Thus, when buying, attention should be paid to the ingredients so that no allergic reaction is experienced. (9)
Why are preservative-free eye sprays important?
There are also preservatives that disrupt the stability of the greasy film, leading to further dry, irritated eyes.
It is not absolutely necessary for eye sprays to contain preservatives, as the development of germs is considered a very low risk.
However, the disadvantage with eye sprays without preservatives is that the spray should be used up within the specified time frame after opening. (10)
Image source: Kalea Jerielle / unsplash
Khaireddin R, Schmidt KG. Vergleichende Untersuchung zur Therapie des evaporativen trockenen Auges [Comparative investigation of treatments for evaporative dry eye]. Klin Monbl Augenheilkd. 2010 Feb;227(2):128-34. German. doi: 10.1055/s-0028-1109686. Epub 2009 Sep 15. PMID: 19757354.
Bradley, Samantha: Understanding the benefits of liposomal eye sprays for dry eye patients. Supplements, Focus on Dry Eye, online | URI: 20201638
Definition und Klassifikation des trockenen Auges: Bericht des Unterausschusses für Definition und Klassifikation des International Dry Eye WorkShop 2007. The Ocular Surface 2007 (5) 75-92
Wang MT, Ganesalingam K, Loh CS, Alberquerque T, Al-Kanani S, Misra SL, Craig JP. Compatibility of phospholipid liposomal spray with silicone hydrogel contact lens wear. Cont Lens Anterior Eye. 2017 Feb;40(1):53-58. doi: 10.1016/j.clae.2016.11.002. Epub 2016 Nov 28. PMID: 27908604.
Hueck, A. and Wehrmann, R. (2017) Comparison of the Clinical Efficacy of Four Different Liposomal Sprays for the Treatment of Dry Eye. Open Journal of Ophthalmology, 7, 103-116. doi: 10.4236/ojoph.2017.72015.
Craig JP, Purslow C, Murphy PJ, Wolffsohn JS. Effect of a liposomal spray on the pre-ocular tear film. Cont Lens Anterior Eye. 2010 Apr;33(2):83-7. doi: 10.1016/j.clae.2009.12.007. Epub 2010 Jan 21. PMID: 20096622.
Pult H, Gill F, Riede-Pult BH. Effect of three different liposomal eye sprays on ocular comfort and tear film. Cont Lens Anterior Eye. 2012 Oct;35(5):203-7; quiz 243-4. doi: 10.1016/j.clae.2012.05.003. Epub 2012 Jun 15. PMID: 22705318.
Bitop AG (2019): Vergleich von Ectoin®-haltigen Augentropfen und Ectoin®-haltigem Augenspray mit den Eye Spray Tears Again®
Walsh, Karen, and Lyndon Jones. “The use of preservatives in dry eye drops.” Clinical ophthalmology (Auckland, N.Z.) vol. 13 1409-1425. 1 Aug. 2019, doi:10.2147/OPTH.S211611