Last updated: August 10, 2021

Our method

28Products analysed

29Hours spent

25Evaluated articles

102User reviews

Welcome to our big eyebrow pencil test 2021. Here we present all the eyebrow pencils we have tested in detail. We have compiled detailed background information and added a summary of customer reviews on the internet.

We would like to make your purchase decision easier and help you find the best eyebrow pencil for you.

You will also find answers to frequently asked questions in our guide. If available, we also offer interesting test videos. Furthermore, you will also find some important information on this page that you should definitely pay attention to if you want to buy an eyebrow pencil.




Summary

  • For many, the eyebrow pencil is already a must during the make-up routine. People who do not naturally have full and bushy eyebrows can give them more shape and fullness with an eyebrow pencil.
  • In principle, a distinction is made between twist-out eyebrow pencils, sharpenable eyebrow pencils and an eyebrow pencil with a felt tip, whereby these are available in different shades and price ranges.
  • Before buying an eyebrow pencil, match it to your hair colour and eye colour so that the colours harmonise.

The Best Eyebrow Pencil: Our Picks

Guide: Questions you should ask yourself before buying an eyebrow pencil

Who is an eyebrow pencil suitable for?

In principle, anyone can use an eyebrow pencil, because the range of applications for eyebrow pencils is diverse.

The eyebrow pencil is often used by people whose eyebrow is quite narrow and consists of only a few hairs. The eyebrow pencil can be used to trace the contours or the entire eyebrow, to touch up areas with fewer hairs or to correct uneven eyebrows.

Frauengesicht

With the right eyebrow colour, you bring out your eye colour better. (Image source: pixabay.com / StockSnap)

Eyebrow pencils are just as suitable for men who want to give their face more expressiveness. Eyebrows are very important for the expressiveness of the eyes and face, so men can also highlight their eyebrows.

However, you should be aware that there are many different eyebrow products that are not suitable for everyone. If you have sensitive skin or are allergic to certain cosmetics, you should use an eyebrow pencil that you can tolerate.

Which eyebrow pencil colour suits me?

The type of eyebrow pencil that suits you best depends on your hair and skin colour, hair volume and shape.

When choosing the right shade, always take your hair colour into account. The colour should not be lighter than your hair, otherwise the eyebrows will fade too much.

Always consider the natural colour of your eyebrows and your own eye colour to achieve the best possible result.

What is the best way to emphasise my eye colour?

Eye colour Application
Blue eyes Blue eyes usually have a bright, friendly look, so this cannot be emphasised with a dark colour. With a dark colour it looks quite harsh, but lighter brown tones are still recommended.
Green eyes Perfect here would be a light brown with a slight olive tinge or with a green tint. The colour of your eyebrows is a great way to accentuate the natural colour of your eyes.
Brown eyes These look best with a dark brown eyebrow pencil, which may even contain shades of your own eyes.

Which eyebrow pencil matches my hair?

Factors such as undertone can also be decisive when choosing a colour. The undertone should always match your own hair and eyebrow colour.

You can find the right shade for brown hair by first analysing your hair type.

If you are a cool hair type, choose an eyebrow pencil in a cool, rather ashy colour like Ash Brown or Grey. Because of the reddish pigments in warm browns, the colour of your eyebrows and your hair may not match after make-up.

Do you have a warm hair colour? Then use shades with a warm colour like Ash Blond. This way you avoid that there is not much difference to your eyebrows and hair tone and you guarantee a natural result.

If you have blonde hair and your eyebrows are very light, then the complexion also plays a big role. If you have a pink skin tone, choose an eyebrow pencil with red pigments, otherwise go for a more ashy shade.

If you don't have any red in your hair or complexion, go for a light-ash colour. You can choose a lighter or darker eyebrow pencil from the countless shades of brown, depending on the brightness of your hair colour.

For people with natural red or red coloured hair, choosing an eyebrow pencil is more difficult. For reddish hair, a light brown pencil would be very suitable.

Still can't find the right eyebrow pencil? Try a lip liner in different shades of red or reddish-brown, as these can also be used as eyebrow pencils.

How do I apply eyebrow pencil correctly?

Before you start drawing on your eyebrows, it's important to shape them correctly. With the right steps, you can make your eyebrows really stand out.

Shape your eyebrows

Point of the eyebrow Instructions
Beginning of the eyebrow The ideal starting point is where the pencil and the brow cross. To do this, place the eyebrow brush against the wing of your nose and hold the pencil straight upwards, this way you will also find the beginning of the eyebrow.
Highest point push the brush over the iris (iris of the eye) and the intersection of the iris and brush marks the highest point of the eyebrow.
End point The intersection of the outer corner of the eye and eyebrow shows the optimal end.

After the eyebrow has been shaped correctly, pluck the hairs that are outside the marking. Be careful not to over-pluck.

Make up the eyebrows

Before you start to make up your eyebrows, prepare your urticating:

  • Eyebrow pencil
  • Eyebrow brush (usually included in eyebrow pencils)
  • Eyebrow gel
  1. Comb your eyebrows with an eyebrow brush. Some eyebrow pencils come with an integrated brush, which also makes them easier to use.
  2. Next, start applying the colour. Draw the contours in your desired shape so that you don't draw over the line.
  3. Use the eyebrow pencil to draw fine and gentle strokes, similar to your own hairs, on the eyebrow. Always apply the colour in the direction of hair growth to achieve a natural result.
  4. To blend and evenly distribute the colour, comb the eyebrow.
  5. Note that the front of the eyebrow should be slightly lighter than the back. If the strokes are too dark or the edges too hard, it will look unnatural. You can also use a lighter colour for the front area.
  6. To make sure your eyebrows don't smudge and last long, fix them with an eyebrow gel. Use this in the same way as a brush.

How much does an eyebrow pencil cost?

Eyebrow pencils are available in an extensive variety, in the most diverse colours as well as from the most diverse manufacturers. The financial outlay that has to be made also varies greatly.

The price range is on average between 2-30€.

There is not much difference between the different types of eyebrow pencils; when it comes to the price, it depends more on which manufacturer you choose.

In supermarkets and drugstores, you can buy eyebrow pencils for as little as two euros, but the quality is not particularly good, as the pencils are usually neither waterproof nor highly pigmented.

There are also eyebrow pencils in the middle class and in the higher price segment. The quality of the eyebrow pencils depends very much on the brand.

Ultimately, when deciding between eyebrow pencils, it comes down to which one you can work with better.

What are the alternatives to an eyebrow pencil?

Choosing the right eyebrow product always depends on your own needs. Each product has its own advantages and disadvantages.

In the following section, we will give you a brief overview of the alternatives to eyebrow pencils.

Type Description
Eyebrow powder The eyebrow powders are usually packed in two shades in one palette. Eyebrow powder is perfect for people with thin and light eyebrows. A small brush is used for application, which is usually included in the packaging.
Eyebrow pomade The eyebrow pomade is a solid gel that must be applied with a brush. The eyebrow pomade gives an intense and precise finish. The product is more suitable for advanced users, as the application requires precision.
Eyebrow gel For a very natural look, an eyebrow gel is also suitable. The gel is especially suitable for eyebrows with many hairs that stand in different directions. The eyebrow gel fixes the hairs and gives them a beautiful shape.

When it comes to eyebrow powder, you can actually go back to a good eye shadow. A powder is especially suitable for thin and light eyebrows.

A small brush is usually included to apply the powder. However, this is rarely used because it is very small and impractical. The powder cannot be used to trace thin hairs and is more of a primer.

Decision: What types of eyebrow pencil are there and which is right for you?

If you want to accentuate your brow with an eyebrow pencil, there are three options to choose from:

  • Twist-out eyebrow pencil
  • Sharpenable eyebrow pencil
  • Eyebrow pencil with felt tip

The handling and use of the three different eyebrow pencils each have advantages and disadvantages.

Which type is right for you depends on your own preferences. In the following section, we have described the three alternatives to make your decision easier.

What are the advantages and disadvantages of a twist-out eyebrow pencil?

As the name suggests, it is an eyebrow pencil that can be twisted out. The lead can be unscrewed via a thread at the end or in the middle of the pencil.

Usually, this pencil has two different ends; a firm, fine tip and a brush. With the tip, you can fill in even small gaps with precise and hairs-like strokes and with the brush you can smudge the colour and comb the desired eyebrow shape.

Advantages
  • Evenly natural result
  • tip enables precise work
Disadvantages
  • Little content

The disadvantage is that there is often little product in the eyebrow pencil and it can run out quickly.

But we can give you a tip: Some eyebrow pencils that are supposedly empty still contain a little product. You just have to cut off the tip of the pencil and more content is available.

What are the advantages and disadvantages of a sharpenable eyebrow pencil?

The sharpenable eyebrow pencil is a classic when it comes to highlighting eyebrows. It is easy and uncomplicated to use and the lead is rather harder.

Kajalstifte

The classic eyebrow pencil resembles a pencil or lipliner and is also available in different colours. (Image source: pixabay.com / kinkate)

The pencil is easy to sharpen and we advise you to do this before each application.

The sharpenable eyebrow pencil is a classic when it comes to highlighting eyebrows. It's simple and easy to use and the lead tends to be harder.

The pencil is easy to sharpen and we advise you to do this before each application.

Use a cosmetic sharpener rather than a pencil sharpener as the lead can break off quickly.

Advantages
  • Lots of product
  • Good coverage
Disadvantages
  • Sharpening needed

In contrast to the twist-out eyebrow pencil, this one contains a lot of product. Due to the creamy and hard consistency, it has good coverage.

It also usually comes with a brush that can be used for blending. You can also achieve a particularly precise and colour-intensive result.

What distinguishes an eyebrow pencil with a felt tip and what are the advantages and disadvantages?

The last type of eyebrow pencil is a liquid eyebrow pencil with a felt tip. There are several variations of the tips. They are available with three tips or four tips.

With the felt tip pen, application is very quick, while pencils with a hard lead need to warm up on the skin first.

Advantages
  • Often waterproof
  • Very good durability
Disadvantages
  • Can dry out very quickly
  • Often no brush included

On hot days or when you sweat during sports, the eyebrow pencil with felt tip is very suitable because it is waterproof. It is also known for its good durability.

However, if you forget to close the cap once, the pencil usually dries out quickly or dries up very quickly. This means that the pen dries in different places, as the tip is thin, it dries first. Therefore, if you use it more than once, the precision may not be the same as the first time.

Buying criteria: Use these factors to compare and evaluate eyebrow pencils

In the following section, we will show you which aspects you can use to decide between the many eyebrow pencils.

  • Precision
  • Ingredients
  • Features

In the following paragraphs, we will explain what the individual criteria are.

Precision

The different types of eyebrows also play an important role in terms of precision.

With the classic eyebrow pencils, it is possible to work precisely at the beginning, but when the lead wears out, it is no longer guaranteed.

In addition, hard leads are difficult to apply, so applications with a creamy consistency are better.

Eyebrow pencils with a bevelled lead are no longer sharp enough to draw very fine strokes after some use. On the other hand, eyebrow pencils with a felt tip are particularly precise, but not colour-intensive.

Likewise, for precise work, the eyebrow pencil should be as soft as possible, because on the one hand a hard pencil can be unpleasant to apply and on the other hand it can irritate the skin. It takes practice to work cleanly and precisely.

Ingredients

Eyebrow pencils sometimes contain critical ingredients like other cosmetic products. We have summarised the most important information about ingredients such as parabens or mineral oil.

Parabens are used as a cheap preservative in various cosmetics. They are criticised because of their oestrogenic effect, as it is possible that the hormone balance can be influenced by their accumulation in the human body. Therefore, we recommend that you buy eyebrow pencils that are free of parabens.

Other ingredients that should be avoided in your eyebrow pencil are mineral oils, as they can reduce water loss from the skin. The skin can't breathe under the colour and this causes the natural regeneration process to slow down.

Properties

In addition to precision and ingredients, properties such as water resistance and the hardness of the eyebrow pencil also play an important role.

The eyebrow pencil should highlight the eyebrows and emphasise the natural beauty. In addition, it should give shape and volume to the eyebrows and colour an inconspicuous eyebrow.

Above all, the eyebrow pencil should be waterproof, otherwise the make-up on the eyebrows could quickly run.

In addition, the lead should be neither hard nor too soft. The hard lead can give little colour and a pencil that is too soft can paint dark bars at best.

Facts worth knowing about eyebrow pencils

What tips and tricks are there for applying eyebrow pencils?

If you are wondering how to remove make-up from your eyebrow, we have the answer for you.

You can remove your eyebrows with any commercially available facial cleanser. In general, eyebrow pencils are easy to remove.

We have listed all the tools you need to make up your eyebrows:

  • Eyebrow pencil
  • Eyebrow brush
  • Eyebrow gel
  • Highlighter / Concealer
  • Tweezers
  • Mirror
  • Good light

Another tip is that you can achieve a perfect finish with a concealer and highlighter. After you have finished your eyebrows, you can use the concealer to cover up imperfections such as red spots or small pimples around the brow.

Use the highlighter to emphasise the brow. Apply the highlighter with a thin brush under the eyebrows and then above the highest part of the eyebrows. This visually lifts and highlights the eyebrows.

How do made-up eyebrows last longer?

To make the eyebrow pencil last longer, use a transparent or coloured eyebrow gel that is similar to mascara.

After making up your eyebrows, apply it and use it to set the colour and brow. If you want it to last for several days, use eyebrow products that are abrasion and water resistant.

Wimperntusche

With an eyebrow gel you can extend the durability and thus the whole day. (Image source: pixabay.com / Bru-nO)

If you haven't used a gel, you should definitely fix the eyebrows you have drawn. This way they will keep their beautiful shape much longer and won't smudge so easily.

You can use hairspray and fixing spray, which you spray onto a small brush and brush over the hairs.

How can I prolong the life of an eyebrow pencil?

It can happen that an eyebrow pencil dries out, no longer gives off the right colour and even breaks off. You can simply take the pencil and hold it over a fire until it starts to melt.

Only when everything has cooled down can you carefully try it out. After this procedure, the outdated eyebrow pencil is as good as new and can be used without any problems.

Frauengesicht

A dried-up eyebrow pencil does not have to end up directly in the trash. With simple tricks, it can still be used. (Image source: Pixabay.com / C-Scott)

If the powder has dried up, you can reapply it with a highly pigmented eye shadow. It is very important to note that you use pure ethanol or a good setting spray.

High-end vs. drugstore: is there a difference?

Is there a difference between drugstore products and high-end products?

High-end products are those that are backed by big names and have been established as beauty producers for a long time.

Manufacturers such as Chanel, Estée Lauder and Nars set new trends with their eyebrow products, which the smaller and cheaper brands copy.

Drugstore products basically offer the same range. Most of the time, they follow the trends from the US.

There are definitely high-end products that produce fairly high-quality products for their price. In most cases, however, you pay for the brand name and the prestige associated with such companies!

However, many make-up fans agree: yes, there is a difference, but it is so small that you almost don't see it.

Image source: pixabay.com / StockSnap

Reviews