Last updated: August 12, 2021

Our method

40Products analysed

34Hours spent

28Evaluated articles

140User reviews

Welcome to our big throat lozenge test 2022. Here we present all the throat lozenges that we have tested. We have compiled detailed background information and added a summary of customer reviews on the internet.

We would like to make your purchase decision easier and help you find the best throat lozenges for you.

You will also find answers to frequently asked questions in our guide. If available, we also offer interesting test videos. Furthermore, you will also find some important information on this page that you should be aware of when buying throat lozenges.


  • If you have a scratchy throat or a cold coming on, it is easy to reach for throat or cough sweets. However, these are not medicines, but strictly speaking count as sweets, as they can at most alleviate discomfort.
  • When eating throat lozenges, you should be careful not to eat too many, as most contain sugar or sweeteners that are high in calories.
  • If you want to use throat lozenges for infants or children, or if you are pregnant or breastfeeding, be well informed, as there are a number of things to consider. These include, for example, the size of the sweets and the herbs they contain, which some people should avoid.

The Best Sore Throat: Our Picks

Guide: Questions you should ask yourself before buying throat lozenges.

What are throat lozenges and when are they used?

Throat lozenges are sometimes called cough or cold lozenges and are actually sweets, not medicines.

However, because they usually contain herbs or other beneficial ingredients, they can certainly help with sore throats or colds.

There are many different types and recipes of throat lozenges, which is why different effects can be produced depending on the ingredients.

However, the aim of all sweets is to stop or dull the pain or scratchiness in the throat by sucking on them. They are often used, especially when a cold starts, because they are easy to get without a prescription and you don't have to take medicine right away.

Who are throat lozenges suitable for?

Actually, throat lozenges are suitable for adults as well as children. Only infants should not be given them because they could choke on them. Some throat lozenges should also be avoided during pregnancy and breastfeeding.

Throat lozenges are also usually very popular with children, but you should keep an eye on their consumption so that they do not consume too much sugar. (Image source: / homar)

Some children already understand how to suck sweets from around the age of two, so this rule does not have to be followed for every child. There are also smaller sweets for children that are more suitable.

If you are pregnant, it is better to avoid throat lozenges with mint and sage, as they are water-reducing, and to consume them in smaller quantities if possible.

If you are breastfeeding your baby, you should also avoid sage as it can inhibit milk production. In addition, you should avoid any throat lozenges with essential oils, as these can change the taste of the milk, which could cause your child to refuse the breast.

If you have any questions or are unsure, you should ask at a pharmacy, especially if your baby is pregnant or breastfeeding.

What do I have to keep in mind when taking throat lozenges?

When taking throat lozenges, especially with children, you must make sure that the lozenge is not swallowed and which ingredients have been used.

Some throat lozenges are made with sugar. However, since people like to suck a few pieces a day, you should be careful not to consume too many calories. They can also cause tooth decay and have a laxative effect in large quantities.

But even sugar-free throat lozenges rarely have fewer calories. In addition, they often contain a sweetener that is not yet known to be harmful to health. Therefore, you should avoid excessive consumption of these sweets.

What are the alternatives to throat lozenges?

Depending on the symptoms you have, different alternatives can be useful. On the one hand, you can buy pastilles or solutions in the pharmacy, but on the other hand, medication may also be necessary. However, there are also many home remedies that can help with sore throats or similar symptoms.

If throat lozenges don't help or your symptoms last for several days, you should see a doctor or ask at the pharmacy.

Other options include cough lozenges and other cough syrups for sore throats. If you don't want to buy throat lozenges or want to be sure that they are made from good ingredients, you can make your own. You can find instructions on how to do this in the Trivia section.

Decision: What types of throat lozenges are there and which are right for you?

Sore throat sweets can be roughly divided into those with essential oils and those with herbal extracts. We will now introduce you to the advantages and disadvantages of each.

When using throat lozenges, please note that they are strictly speaking sweets and not medicines.

The effects that manufacturers often advertise may occur, but this does not have to be the case. If you have severe or long-lasting symptoms, you should consult a doctor!

What are the characteristics of throat lozenges with essential oils and what are their advantages and disadvantages?

These throat lozenges contain essential oils from herbs or other substances containing oils. Menthol, eucalyptus or mint oil are often used here, although the quantities in a single sweet are very small.

The advantage of these sweets is that they moisten the throat and thus prevent germs from settling.

  • Moisturise the throat and prevent germs from settling
  • Soothe scratchy throat
  • Make it easier to cough up secretions
  • Can promote healthy immune system functions
  • In large quantities, essential oils can promote allergies
  • Thyme and sage can increase blood pressure
  • Some oils should not be taken during pregnancy or breastfeeding

It also relieves possible scratching in the throat and makes it easier to cough up secretions. In addition, special combinations of oils can promote the natural function of the immune system.

However, if you consume such throat lozenges in large quantities, you may experience allergic reactions if you are allergic to citrus oils.

In addition, thyme or sage can increase blood pressure, which is why people with high blood pressure are advised not to use throat lozenges containing these substances. Furthermore, some substances should not be used during pregnancy or breastfeeding, or only in small quantities.

What are the characteristics of throat lozenges with herbal extracts and what are their advantages and disadvantages?

These throat lozenges contain small amounts of herbal extracts and can therefore help with sore throats and similar complaints. Sage, ribwort or marshmallow are often used here. You can also often find throat lozenges with herbal mixtures.

  • Herbal extracts have a soothing effect on the bronchial tubes and mucous membranes
  • they calm coughs and cough irritation
  • these throat lozenges can support free breathing
  • In pregnancy, it is better to consult a doctor before taking them
  • The herbs are only contained in the throat lozenges in small quantities, which is why their effect has not yet been confirmed

The advantage of these throat lozenges is that the herbal extracts are beneficial for the bronchial tubes and mucous membranes and can calm coughs and coughing. In addition, free breathing can be supported.

However, it is better to consult a doctor or pharmacist before using these sweets during pregnancy.

Since the herbal extracts are only added in small quantities, their beneficial effect cannot be clearly attributed to the herbs, which is why their effect is sometimes doubted.

Buying criteria: Use these factors to compare and evaluate throat lozenges

We have decided to use the following criteria to compare throat lozenges:

  • Ingredients
  • Effect
  • Area of application
  • Target group

We will now describe each criterion in more detail and explain what you should look out for.


When it comes to ingredients, there are often many different ones used and there are correspondingly different recipes. However, you will often find honey, lemon or a mixture of herbs.

Since sweets are traditionally made from sugar, this is also often a main ingredient.

There are many different combinations of herbs, which also have different effects, which we will discuss in more detail in the next point.

However, sage, thyme, ribwort, menthol or eucalypthus are often used.

These are typical herbs that have an expectorant or calming effect and are supposed to support the body during a cold. That is why they are often grown in home gardens and used in various forms, such as tea, for colds.

When it comes to ingredients, you should be aware that many contain sugar or sweeteners, which you should not consume in excess. You can read more about what else you should consider in our advice section above.


There are two different types of throat lozenges. On the one hand, there are expectorant ingredients and on the other hand, there are those that soothe the cough. Some also contain substances that have a local anaesthetic effect.

The expectorants include thyme and fennel. The essential oils are usually responsible for the ingredients that relieve cough irritation, as they promote saliva production and thus moisten the throat.

Sage or ribwort can be named as representatives here. We have summarised the properties of other common herbs here:

Herb or. Ingredient effect
Thyme anti-inflammatory, expectorant and cough-relieving
Fennel antibacterial, relaxing and expectorant
Sage analgesic and antibacterial
Peppermint anti-inflammatory and analgesic
eucalyptus analgesic and disinfectant
menthol cooling and analgesic
ribwort anti-inflammatory, antibacterial and cough-relieving
honey antibacterial and cough-relieving

Range of application

Depending on your symptoms, certain ingredients may be more suitable for you. However, it depends on the severity of your symptoms whether throat lozenges are the right choice or not, as medication should be used for severe symptoms.

Generally, throat lozenges are used for sore throats, coughs and other forms of colds. However, as already mentioned in the last point, they are mainly used to loosen mucus or to relieve cough irritation.

They can also help with sore throats. We have summarised here which ingredients are best suited for which symptoms:

symptoms suitable ingredients
congested bronchial tubes thyme, fennel or camomile
cough thyme, ribwort or honey
sore throat sage, peppermint, eucalyptus, Indian water astragalus or menthol
cold thyme, fennel, sage, peppermint, eucalyptus, ribwort, Indian water astragalus or honey

Target group

Another crucial factor is the person for whom the throat lozenges are intended. This is because, for example, children or pregnant women as well as nursing mothers should take other throat lozenges.

People with certain health problems, such as high blood pressure, should also avoid some sweets because of the ingredients.

We have already described which sweets are suitable for whom in the guide above, but if you are unsure, it is better to ask a doctor or pharmacist for advice.

Facts about throat lozenges

Why do throat lozenges work?

The various manufacturers of throat lozenges boast that their particular formulation is particularly effective against sore throats or similar complaints.

Most of the ingredients are designed to have an expectorant and decongestant effect, which can clear the airways.

In some cases, local pain relief can even be achieved. However, this does not fight the causes of the cold, but only alleviates the discomfort.

Did you know that sweets help simply by sucking them? This produces saliva that soothes the throat, at least in the short term, just like drinking lots of tea.

How long and how often can I use throat lozenges?

In principle, you can use throat lozenges as long and as often as you like. However, especially if they contain sugar, you should be careful not to eat too many, as they can cause tooth decay and contain a lot of calories.

However, sugar-free varieties are often no less calorific and should not be used excessively because of the sweeteners they contain.

When should I go to the doctor with a sore throat or cough?

It is generally advised to see a doctor if the symptoms are severe or if the illness lasts longer than three to four days.

However, there are risk groups that should see a doctor sooner and often have more severe symptoms. These include children, the elderly and pregnant women, as well as people with immunodeficiency diseases.

Ärtze von erkältung-onlineüber stärker ausgeprägte Symptome

You don't know when to go to the doctor when you have a cold? That depends on your illness and the symptoms that go with it. In most cases, you can cure a mild cold yourself. However, if the symptoms are very severe, a visit to the doctor is advisable.

  • sudden high fever over 39 degrees Celsius
  • severe feeling of illness
  • Pain in the forehead, sinuses or eyes
  • purulent or bloody sputum
  • Pain when breathing and coughing
  • Cough that lasts longer than three weeks

You can usually tell when you need to see a doctor by the severity of your cold. If your general cold symptoms last more than three to four days, a visit to the doctor is definitely recommended.


Image source: